American Crew After Shave Toner for Men, Facial Toner that Soothes Skin, 5.1 Fl Oz Review
Our verdict
American Crew's After Shave Toner is a soothing, unscented lotion built around aloe vera, allantoin and menthol, designed to calm skin right after shaving rather than function as a daily skincare toner. It is a solid pick for anyone who wants a fast, cooling finish after a razor pass.
Check price on AmazonBest for
Anyone who wants a soothing, unscented lotion to calm and refresh skin immediately after shaving.
Skip if
You want a traditional facial toner for a daily skincare routine rather than a post-shave calming step.
- Priced 73% above the category median ($19.20 across 452 tracked models)
Our scorecard
-
Owner rating4.3/5
4.3 average across 280 owner ratings
-
Popularity2.2/5
280 owner reviews, fewer than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other women's everyday face care: moisturizers, face mists, facial kits, rollers, cleansing brushes and steamers we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
This is a lotion-form after shave toner rather than a classic liquid facial toner, formulated with aloe vera, allantoin and menthol to soothe freshly shaved skin. It is unscented and labeled for all skin types, packaged in a 5.1 fl oz bottle at $33.15.
The listed benefits focus on softening, smoothing, soothing and moisturizing, which lines up with its role as an after shave step rather than an exfoliating or brightening toner. Menthol gives it a cooling sensation, while aloe vera and allantoin are known for calming irritated skin.
At 280 reviews and a 4.3 rating, feedback is solidly positive without being exceptional, which is typical for a straightforward grooming product used consistently by a smaller base of repeat buyers.
Pros
- Unscented formula suitable for sensitive, freshly shaved skin
- Contains aloe vera and allantoin, both known for their calming properties
- Menthol provides a cooling, refreshing sensation after shaving
- Dermatologically tested per the listing
Cons
- Premium price at $33.15 for 5.1 fl oz
- Marketed as an after shave product, not a general daily facial toner
- Menthol may feel too intense for those with very sensitive skin
- Low bought-last-month figure suggests a smaller, niche following
Performance notes
Aloe vera and allantoin are well-established calming ingredients that support the appearance of comfort in irritated or freshly shaved skin, while menthol adds an immediate cooling effect. This formula is built to soothe post-shave redness and tightness rather than to exfoliate or treat specific skin concerns, so it functions more like a calming after-care lotion than a traditional acid or astringent toner.
What buyers say
A 4.3 rating from 280 reviews reflects a generally satisfied but modest customer base, consistent with a specialty grooming product rather than a mass-market skincare toner. Buyers appear to value the cooling, soothing effect over any broader skincare claims.
Similar women's everyday face care: moisturizers, face mists, facial kits, rollers, cleansing brushes and steamers to consider
Frequently asked questions
Can this be used as a regular facial toner instead of just after shaving?
It is formulated as an after shave lotion with a cooling, soothing profile, so while it can be applied to the face generally, it does not contain the acids or brightening ingredients found in typical daily facial toners. It works best as a calming step after shaving rather than a full skincare toner.
Is the menthol scent noticeable even though it is labeled unscented?
The listing describes the scent as unscented, though menthol itself does carry a natural cooling sensation on the skin even without added fragrance. Reviewers generally describe the feel as refreshing rather than overpowering.