Palmer's Skin Success Deep Cleansing Facial Astringent With Vitamin E, 8.5 Ounce (Pack of 4) - Packaging May Vary Review
Our verdict
Palmer's Skin Success Deep Cleansing Facial Astringent brings a menthol scented, vitamin E enriched formula to normal skin at a solid value price of $28.56 for four 8.5 ounce bottles. With a 4.1 star average from 254 reviews, it holds up as a dependable everyday toner rather than a flashy new launch.
Check price on AmazonBest for
Normal skin types who want a straightforward, cooling astringent toner with vitamin E, especially if you go through toner quickly and want a multi bottle pack.
Skip if
You have dry or sensitive skin, since a menthol scented astringent formula can feel stripping. Also skip if you prefer fragrance free or alcohol free formulas, as astringents in this style typically favor a refreshing, tingly finish over gentle hydration.
- Priced 49% above the category median ($19.20 across 452 tracked models)
Our scorecard
-
Owner rating4.1/5
4.1 average across 254 owner ratings
-
Popularity1.9/5
254 owner reviews, fewer than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other women's everyday face care: moisturizers, face mists, facial kits, rollers, cleansing brushes and steamers we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
["Palmer's built this astringent around deep cleansing, refreshing, and toning, with vitamin E added for antioxidant support. The menthol scent gives it a cooling, spa like finish that many people associate with a hardworking toner, though that same tingle can be too intense for reactive skin.", 'The pack of four 8.5 ounce bottles, 34 fluid ounces total, makes this one of the better value options in the category on a per ounce basis, which matters if toner is a daily step in your routine.', 'With 254 reviews and a 4.1 star average, the product has a reasonable amount of feedback behind it. That is not the review volume of a bestseller, but it is enough to suggest the formula performs as described for most buyers with normal skin.']
Pros
- Vitamin E added for antioxidant support
- Menthol scent gives a refreshing, cooling feel
- Pack of 4 bottles, 34 fl oz total, offers strong value per ounce
- Cruelty free formulation
- Listed for cleansing, refreshing, and toning in one step
Cons
- Formulated for normal skin, not ideal for dry or sensitive skin
- Menthol scent may be too strong for fragrance sensitive users
- 4.1 star rating trails some higher rated toners in this category
- No alcohol free claim listed, so those avoiding alcohol should check further
Performance notes
Vitamin E is an antioxidant that may help support the look of healthy skin when included in a topical formula. The menthol scent is likely responsible for the refreshing sensation many astringents in this category are known for, though menthol can also cause tingling or mild irritation on more reactive skin. Marketed benefits are deep cleansing, refreshing, and toning, which lines up with a traditional astringent role, prepping skin before moisturizer rather than replacing it.
What buyers say
A 4.1 star average across 254 reviews suggests generally positive experiences, though it is not the runaway rating some rosewater style toners in this set achieve. This pattern is typical of astringent formulas, which tend to please people who like a stronger, more active feeling toner while occasionally not suiting those with drier or more reactive skin.
More from Palmer's
Similar women's everyday face care: moisturizers, face mists, facial kits, rollers, cleansing brushes and steamers to consider
Frequently asked questions
Is this Palmer's toner alcohol based?
The listed ingredients highlight vitamin E and a menthol scent, but the product does not specify an alcohol free claim. If you are trying to avoid alcohol in your toner, check the full ingredient list on the packaging before buying, since traditional astringents sometimes include it for the cleansing effect.
How many bottles come in this pack?
This listing includes four 8.5 ounce bottles, for 34 fluid ounces total. That is a generous supply for daily use and one of the reasons this option offers strong value per ounce compared to single bottle toners.
Is the menthol scent strong?
Menthol is called out as the scent name, and astringents with menthol typically deliver a noticeable cooling, tingly sensation on application. If you prefer a very mild or fragrance free toner, this may feel more intense than you are used to.