Thayers Alcohol-free Unscented Witch Hazel and Aloe Vera Formula Toner 12 oz. (Pack of 2) Review
Our verdict
The alcohol free, unscented version of Thayers' classic witch hazel toner, formulated with 13% witch hazel extract and aloe vera for a gentler daily toning routine.
Check price on AmazonBest for
Normal skin types who want the trusted Thayers witch hazel formula without alcohol or added fragrance.
Skip if
You prefer the classic scented Thayers astringent, since this unscented alcohol free version has a different feel and no added fragrance.
- Priced 39% above the category median ($19.20 across 452 tracked models)
Our scorecard
-
Owner rating4.6/5
4.6 average across 488 owner ratings
-
Popularity3.1/5
488 owner reviews, more than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other women's everyday face care: moisturizers, face mists, facial kits, rollers, cleansing brushes and steamers we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
This Thayers 2-pack includes two 12 fluid ounce bottles of the brand's Alcohol Free Unscented Witch Hazel and Aloe Vera Toner, for 24 fluid ounces combined. The formula uses aloe barbadensis leaf juice alongside witch hazel extract at 13 percent, which the brand describes as a natural astringent that helps tighten the look of pores, reduce the appearance of inflammation, and soothe the skin.
By skipping alcohol and fragrance, this version is built for people who like the classic Thayers witch hazel effect but want a gentler experience overall. It is also free of parabens, phthalates, sulfates, talc, and formaldehyde, and it carries natural and organic material features, rounding out a clean-leaning ingredient profile.
With 488 ratings averaging 4.6 out of 5 stars, this alcohol free version holds up well against Thayers' more traditional astringent. Reviewers appear to value having the same trusted brand and witch hazel benefit without the sting that alcohol based toners can bring.
Pros
- Alcohol free and unscented, which reduces irritation risk compared to the original astringent
- Contains 13% witch hazel extract alongside aloe vera for soothing benefit
- Free of parabens, phthalates, sulfates, talc, and formaldehyde
- Strong 4.6 star average across 488 reviews
- 2-pack of 12 oz bottles offers good value for regular users
Cons
- No fragrance, which some who prefer the scented original Thayers may miss
- Bought last month figure is not available, making current demand harder to gauge
- Alcohol free formula may feel less immediately refreshing than the original astringent for some users
Performance notes
The formula pairs aloe barbadensis leaf juice, used mainly for its calming and moisturizing qualities, with witch hazel extract at 13 percent, a natural astringent that may help with the look of tightened pores and reduced irritation. Removing alcohol from the formula keeps the astringent benefit while lowering the potential for dryness or sensitivity that alcohol based toners can cause.
What buyers say
A 4.6 star average from 488 reviews shows this alcohol free version holds strong appeal alongside Thayers' more traditional formula. Feedback suggests buyers appreciate the gentler profile without giving up the witch hazel effect the brand is known for.
More from Brand
Similar women's everyday face care: moisturizers, face mists, facial kits, rollers, cleansing brushes and steamers to consider
Frequently asked questions
How is this different from Thayers' original Witch Hazel Astringent?
This version is alcohol free and unscented, while the original astringent contains alcohol and a natural witch hazel scent. Both use witch hazel and aloe vera, but this formula is designed to be gentler for those who find the original too drying or strong smelling.
Is this toner suitable for sensitive skin?
The alcohol free, fragrance free, and paraben free formula makes this a reasonable choice for more sensitive skin types compared to traditional astringents. As always, patch testing is a good idea before adding any new toner to a sensitive skin routine.
What percentage of witch hazel does this contain?
The formula lists witch hazel extract at 13 percent, combined with aloe vera for added soothing and moisturizing benefit. This concentration is meant to provide a mild astringent effect without the alcohol found in Thayers' original formula.